Few franchises are harder to discuss in today’s climate than Harry Potter. Once considered the defining literary saga of the 21st century and a cultural phenomenon beloved worldwide, Potter is now a far more contentious subject. There’s, of course, the behind-the-scenes, mounting controversies of its author, J.K. Rowling, which were enough to stain the saga for countless fans the world over. There’s also the fact that, looking back at it, the books aren’t exactly the peak of fantasy writing, attracting criticism for their worldbuilding, characterization, and perceived politics.
Yet, it’s also impossible to deny that Harry Potter remains a huge part of pop culture, with theme parks, video games, and even a reboot series coming to HBO later this year. But how do the books measure against that influence? Sure, they’re not perfect, and their many flaws have become more noticeable with age, but the story of the Boy Who Lived is quite riveting, enchanting an entire generation of readers. Here, we’ll rank all seven Harry Potter books based on their narrative, characterization, plot developments, and Rowling’s writing. None of the books are bad per se, but some are far stronger, and the weakest elements of the saga have only gotten more noticeable in the years since.
7
‘Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince’ (2005)
The sixth book in the series is probably the most singular, too. Harry’s sixth year at Hogwarts sees him dealing with one of his toughest challenges yet: adolescent troubles. Mainly, he discovers his crush on Ron’s younger sister, Ginny, and navigates his complicated feelings about it. On a large-scale, the plot also features most of Lord Voldemort’s backstory and introduces the concept of Horcruxes, items in which Voldemort has put a piece of his soul to effectively become immortal.
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince is a curious and uneven book. On the one hand, everything concerning Voldemort’s backstory is quite riveting, and the chapters centered on it are as close as Potter ever came to horror. On the other hand, most of the book is greatly focused on Harry, Ron, and Hermione’s romance woes and, simply put, Rowling is rather bad at writing teen drama. Harry’s relationship with Ginny is never convincing, and the metaphor of him having a beast in his chest that reacts every time he sees her is uncomfortable at best and outright laughable at worst. The Horcruxes also come out of nowhere, and while the concept is good, it should’ve been introduced far sooner to make an even bigger impact; arriving at the sixth hour, it comes across as a convenience rather than a natural development. Half-Blood Prince is one of two Potter novels that’s entirely character-driven, and unlike the other one, the approach doesn’t entirely work.
6
‘Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets’ (1998)
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets is the second novel in the series, focusing on Harry’s sophomore year at Hogwarts. It begins with the appearance of Dobby, the house elf, who warns Harry not to go back to school and desperately attempts to sabotage the boy’s attempts. At Hogwarts, Harry discovers the Chamber of Secrets has been opened again, unleashing an unknown terror that’s targeting many of the school’s most vulnerable students.
This second book is still very much aimed at children, meaning the narrative is straightforward but with a few darker elements compared to its predecessor. The mystery behind the Chamber of Secrets is sufficiently compelling, but it probably needed a few extra pages to actually land. New characters like Dobby, Lucius Malfoy, and Gilderoy Lockhart bring some color to the story, and the introduction of new locations also makes Hogwarts seem more inviting and immersive. Alas, Chamber of Secrets is also the most forgettable entry in the series, a transitional story to a tee meant to take Harry from childhood into early adolescence. The writing is solid, even if it’s also just a rehash of everything Rowling had already done in the first novel.
5
‘Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone’ (1997)
Introducing a new world isn’t easy. The fantasy books with the best worldbuilding must balance several key details, from the world itself to the systems that make it work. The first Potter book does it admirably well, introducing eleven-year-old Harry Potter, who lives a hard life with his abusive aunt and uncle. When he learns he’s actually a wizard and a rather famous member of the magical community, Harry’s life changes forever. He attends Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, makes new friends, and stumbles upon a dangerous mystery.
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone is the shortest book in the series, but it might also be the most effective of the bunch, especially considering how many things it introduces. Here, we get the basics of the story: we meet the main players, are introduced to the main setting and conflict, and get to know the key beats that the overarching story will cover across the next six books. Sure, it’s still very much a children’s book, meaning the writing is simple and engaging but never pedestrian. This first entry set the tone for what would follow, even if subsequent books would abandon its more whimsical approach.
4
‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows’ (2007)
If starting a series is tough, then ending it is that much tougher: the expectations are sky-high, and the chances of satisfying everyone in your fanbase are slim to none. The seventh and last Potter book worked better than many other long-awaited conclusions, but it’s far from the series’ best effort. In it, Harry embarks on a perilous and arduous journey to find and destroy the Horcruxes alongside Ron and Hermione. Meanwhile, Voldemort keeps amassing power across the Wizarding World.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows is a solid conclusion to the Potter saga. The plot abandons the formula used throughout the previous six books and becomes a road book, following Harry, Ron, and Hermione on a journey across the UK. For convenience’s sake, the plot takes a few shortcuts, like keeping all of Voldemort’s Horcruxes within the UK and introducing the all-too-convenient Deathly Hallows, a gimmick that ultimately works, even if it ends up feeling a bit too much like a deus ex machina. The epilogue is overkill, though, closing what has otherwise been a somber, coming-of-age story like a sappy telenovela. But hey, no one can say Harry didn’t earn his happy ending.
3
‘Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire'(2000)
Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire is the point of no return for the series. Hogwarts is hosting the Tri-Wizard Tournament, where seventh-year students compete in a series of dangerous and potentially deadly tasks to win the Tri-Wizard Cup, some money, and “eternal glory” for the school. Logically, Harry’s name is drafted by someone, and he must then enter a competition for which he is woefully unprepared. Meanwhile, a dangerous plot is brewing in the background.
If its predecessor began toying with a darker story, then Goblet of Fire took it to the next level. The book features the best action sequences in the saga, and both the first and last tasks in the Tri-Wizard Tournament are among Rowling’s finest writing moments, truly immersing you in Harry’s headspace and the gravity of the situation. The harrowing ending, in which Cedric Diggory dies, marks the first time Harry, and therefore the reader, experiences death in the series firsthand, effectively ending the childhood portion of the series and throwing the young wizard into a world of non-stop danger. Of course, Goblet of Fire also features the return of Voldemort, in a great sequence full of dread and a sense of mounting horror.
2
‘Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix’ (2003)
Following the bleak fourth chapter, Harry returned with the gloomiest, most depressing book in his saga. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix covers Harry’s fifth year at Hogwarts. While he enjoyed a considerable degree of popularity in the four previous books, this one finds him at his lowest, with the entire Wizarding community turning their backs on him, refusing to believe Voldemort is back. The Ministry of Magic sends the odious Dolores Umbridge to Hogwarts, and she slowly and clinically begins taking control of the school. Meanwhile, Voldemort’s influence grows from the shadows.
Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is the longest book in the series, but it earns its extensive runtime. Harry is at his most complicated here, dealing with a world that is increasingly hostile to him, not to mention the typical woes of adolescence. Yet, crucially, he’s never unlikable per se (he does come awfully close, though). The plot takes its time to build the mystery concerning the prophecy, a plot point that was introduced all the way back in the first book and that reaches a natural and satisfying conclusion here. Moreover, Dolores Umbridge is the saga’s best villain, surpassing Voldemort himself. The character is so detestable, so utterly reprehensible, that one can’t help but cringe every time she shows up.
1
‘Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban’ (1999)
The third book is where the series officially moves away from childhood whimsy and into a more grim version of fantasy. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban sees Harry on high alert following the escape of Sirius Black from Azkaban prison. A dangerous dark wizard, Black has a connection to Harry’s parents, adding a personal element to the danger. To supposedly protect Hogwarts from Black, the Ministry authorizes the presence of dementors, dark creatures that feed on the souls of people, on the grounds.
The third book is the first in the series to be fully character-driven, and it’s the only one that makes the approach work. Harry gets the most development here, learning that the world is not as black-and-white as he previously thought. The passages with the dementors are brilliant, embodying the spirit of dark fantasy to a T — the series overall could’ve benefited from a lot more of that. Of the new characters, Remus Lupin stands out as one of the saga’s most complex, but the wacky Professor Trelawney is also a hoot. The mystery is also incredibly engaging; there’s really no room for mistakes because the plot is so tightly constructed, with one scene flowing into the next seamlessly. Here, Harry stops being a child, and so many of his readers followed suit. Prisoner of Azkaban is the best Harry Potter movie by far, and as it turns out, the book is also the best in the iconic series.
Leave a Reply