Dark Matter Season 2 Is Officially Leaving Blake Crouch’s Novel Behind

Warning: This article includes spoilers for Dark Matter season 2 episodes 1 through 5!

Apple TV’s Dark Matter season 1 used up all of Blake Crouch’s novel, but the show didn’t fully abandon the original story until the halfway point of season 2, moving past it thematically and narratively. Crouch is a beloved writer with more than 30 books under his belt, and his stories have made their way to the screen. It’s not surprising, given hard sci-fi’s major onscreen surge. His most popular onscreen project is Dark Matter, which started releasing in 2024. Recently, the show has returned for a second season, much to the surprise of book fans.

Dark Matter didn’t actually, technically need a second season. Season 1 changed a lot from the book, but its bones were, for the most part, the same. Both start with Jason spending a night with his family, then getting kidnapped. Much like the book, the end of Dark Matter season 1 shows the Dessens fleeing into the multiverse to escape the Jasons. It could have been a miniseries without any sweat, and frankly, many fans originally preferred that option.

However, Apple TV decided that wasn’t enough and moved forward with Dark Matter season 2. Surprisingly, it wasn’t a disaster. Unlike other shows that surpassed their source material, the second season is pretty good. By the halfway point of Dark Matter season 2, it’s clear that the show has fully moved past the original book.

Dark Matter Season 2 Is Going Well Beyond Blake Crouch’s Novel

Ryan and Amanda stand outside looking upset in Dark Matter on Apple TV — Apple TV+’s Dark Matter

Dark Matter officially surpassed the Blake Crouch novel the minute season 2 started. Season 1 changed a lot from the book, but its bones were, for the most part, the same. Both start with Jason spending a night with his family, then getting kidnapped. They both end with the Dessens fleeing into the multiverse to escape the Jasons. The side characters don’t have the same outcomes, though, at the end of Dark Matter season 1, which is crucial to the second season.

That being said, the start of Dark Matter season 2 feels like a natural extension of the book’s story. The Dessens are trying to settle down, but other versions of Jason keep ruining their lives. They keep showing up and trying to get Daniela back. Alternatively, the Jasons from other worlds are too well known or already in the area. The problems the Dessens face are strictly related to the Jasons. They even give an Easter egg nod to a cut Dark Matter book location. However, everything changes as Dark Matter season 2 continues, becoming something well beyond Blake Crouch’s novel.

Much of the attention shifts towards Leighton, Amanda, and Ryan. Jason2 is back in the picture, and the focus on him trying to be a better person is a big deal since he died at the end of Blake Crouch’s book. Dark Matter season 2, episode 4’s big twist defies one of the core values of the original story. By the time Dark Matter season 2, episode 5 rolls around, it’s clear that they’ve abandoned the original premise of the Jasons being a threat. This episode shows that the other Jasons are no longer a constant threat to Jason, Charlie, and Daniela.

Blake Crouch Is Still In Control Of Dark Matter’s Expansion

Dayo Okeniyi as Leighton standing in The Box looking intensely in Dark Matter season 2

Even though Dark Matter has continued to expand beyond the original book, author Blake Crouch controls virtually every step forward in the story. He serves as the creator, showrunner, and writer on the TV show. Even though I was critical of some choices in my review of Dark Matter season 2 for ScreenRant, I thought Blake Crouch largely did a good job extending the story past the original. There’s clear narrative consistency, even when the different plots aren’t all balanced well. I don’t think that would’ve been the case had the original author not controlled so much of the show.

What’s more, he revealed his three-season plan for Dark Matter before Apple TV renewed the show for season 2. The foresight has a few positive impacts. First, Apple TV seems more likely to renew Dark Matter for a third season, since they already knew the plan. Additionally, this offers hope that the narrative will remain consistent from start to end, carrying over the same tone and style. On top of that, Crouch writes hard sci-fi. He knows the science behind the box and quantum mechanics, so he can provide a strong explanation throughout Dark Matter as the sci-fi moves forward.